Main findings
There was no excess prevalence of autism diagnoses in school-age children of mothers with a different national background.
The incidence rate of autism diagnosis was 0.18 % in children of mothers with a different national background than Norway, and 0.12 % in children whose mothers were born in Norway (relative risk 1.5; 95 % confidence interval 0.87 to 2.50).
Of the school-age children who took part in the study, 22 % had received other diagnoses at the same time as their autism diagnosis.
Of the school-age children who were diagnosed with autism, 59 % had already been diagnosed with one or more neuropsychiatric conditions.
The prevalence of autism spectrum disorders is rising, and the reason why is not clear (1). Changes to the diagnostic criteria and increased awareness of the diagnosis may explain much of the increase, but a genuine rise in prevalence cannot be ruled out (2).
Autism spectrum diagnoses cover a broad range of conditions characterised by early deficits in mutual social interaction and patterns of communication, repetitive sensory motor behaviours and restricted interests (3). The prevalence varies with geographical area (4, 5). It is difficult to compare prevalence rates for autism spectrum diagnoses, for example because data are obtained from a variety of sources, including diagnostic registers and population-based studies (6).
There is reason to believe that children who receive an autism diagnosis at the preschool stage have a heavier symptom load than children who receive a referral and are diagnosed at a later stage. Leader et al. found that children with autism and an accompanying intellectual disability received their autism diagnosis significantly earlier than those whose intellectual ability was in the normal range (7). This may also be the case in Norway. A Swedish study that investigated the diagnostic subgroups of childhood autism and Asperger syndrome separately, found a higher risk of childhood autism, but not of Asperger syndrome, when the maternal national background was a country other than Sweden (8). Of the children with childhood autism, 67 % had an accompanying intellectual disability, but it was not reported how many of these had a mother with a different national background. Another Swedish study showed something similar: There was an increased risk of autism in children with comorbid intellectual disability whose parents had an immigrant background, but the risk of autism was lower if there was no comorbid intellectual disability (9). A Finnish study that focused on children with Asperger syndrome found a lower risk when both parents had a different national background (10).
Most studies that investigate the prevalence of autism spectrum disorders do not specify the age of the child at the time of diagnosis (4). The prevalence of autism spectrum disorders in children and adolescents born in Norway in the period 2001–2016 to Norwegian-born mothers was 0.23 % at the age of 2–5 years and 1.54 % in the 14–17 age group (11, Table 3.5). This means that there is an almost seven-fold increase in prevalence between preschool age and adolescence. Similar figures for children whose mothers have a different national background did not show a similarly rising ratio with increasing age.
A recent Norwegian study focused on several developmental disorders among children born in Norway to immigrant parents (12). This study found a higher prevalence of autism spectrum diagnoses, particularly in preschool children. This matches our earlier findings in respect of preschool children in southern Trøndelag diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder (13). Clinically, it appears that the same excess prevalence does not apply for children who are diagnosed at school age. The purpose of this study was therefore to establish the incidence of autism spectrum diagnoses in relation to maternal national background in school-age children, and to identify psychiatric and other neurodevelopmental comorbidities.
Material and method
The study was a retrospective review of the medical journals of children aged 10–16 years in the catchment area of St Olav's Hospital (southern Trøndelag) in the period 2016–2019 who had been diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder, either by the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services or the Child Habilitation Unit. We identified children/adolescents who were of the right age during the relevant period, all of whom were sent information about the study and their right to be excluded. If they were over 16 years of age when the letter was sent out, it was addressed to them. If they were 16 years or younger, the letter was addressed to their parents. The study was considered by the Regional Committee for Medical and Health Research Ethics, Central Norway (Application ID 353116). Referring to the Data Protection Officer's evaluation of the earlier study on preschool children (13), the Research Committee considered that this study was not subject to approval by the Data Protection Officer.
Data obtained from medical records included age, sex, country of birth, subcategory of autism diagnosis (ICD-10 diagnosis codes F84.0 Childhood autism, F84.1 Atypical autism, F84.5 Asperger syndrome, F84.8 Other pervasive developmental disorders and F84.9 Pervasive developmental disorder, unspecified), other neuropsychiatric diagnoses (chapter V of ICD-10 for mental and behavioural disorders, F90 Hyperkinetic disorders and F95 Tics), intellectual disabilities (ICD-10 diagnosis codes F70-F72) and neurological disorders. We also recorded when the various diagnoses were given, by which service, and maternal national background. Population data for St Olav's Hospital's catchment area, southern Trøndelag, were obtained from Statistics Norway.
The incidence rate was calculated as the number of children who received a diagnosis divided by the total number of children of the same age in the population in the relevant period. We reported a 95 % confidence interval (CI) for Relative Risk in Stata 18 and used a two-sided significance level 5 %.
Results
We identified a total of 136 children/adolescents who met the criteria. Of these, ten declined to participate. It proved impossible for other reasons to obtain the medical records of one child. The sample therefore consisted of 125 children, of whom 93 (74 %) were male. Of these, 107 had a mother born in Norway while 18 mothers had a different national background (including six mothers from European countries other than Norway and Russia). This group included nine children who were either adopted from a country other than Norway, or who were born abroad and had moved to Norway with their families. The risk of an autism spectrum diagnosis was 1.5 times higher (95 % confidence interval 0.87 to 2.50) for the children of mothers with a different national background. This difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.11) (Table 1) (14, 15).
Table 1
Incidence rates for autism spectrum diagnoses in school-age children (10–16 years) in southern Trøndelag in the period 2016–2019, by maternal national background (14, 15).
2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | Total | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
All diagnosed children (N) | 28 | 33 | 31 | 33 | 125 | |
Total population (N) | 25 205 | 25 443 | 25 877 | 26 198 | 102 713 | |
Children of mothers born in Norway | Diagnosed (n) | 22 | 30 | 27 | 28 | 107 |
Population (n) | 22 979 | 23 005 | 23 213 | 23 340 | 92 537 | |
Incidence rate (%) | 0.10 | 0.13 | 0.12 | 0.12 | 0.12 | |
Children of mothers with a different national background | Diagnosed (n) | 6 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 18 |
Population (n) | 2 226 | 2 428 | 2 664 | 2 858 | 10 176 | |
Incidence rate (%) | 0.27 | 0.12 | 0.15 | 0.17 | 0.18 | |
Incidence rate for children of mothers with a different national background / children of mothers born in Norway | 2.8 | 0.9 | 1.3 | 1.5 | 1.5 |
The study's mean age at the time of diagnosis was 12.6 years. Of the children in the sample, 106 (85 %) had been diagnosed by the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services, or in hospital, while 19 children (15 %) had been diagnosed by the Child Habilitation Unit. The most frequent diagnosis was Asperger syndrome (of these, 59 children had been diagnosed by the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services, 9 by the Habilitation Unit) and unspecified pervasive developmental disorder (44 and 8 respectively).
A total of 74 children (59.2 %) had been diagnosed with one or more neuropsychiatric disorders before they were diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder. This was most commonly ADHD (n = 51), followed by language disorders and intellectual disabilities, anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorders (Table 2).
Table 2
Existing neuropsychiatric diagnoses in 74 of 125 school-age children (10–16 years) who were diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder in southern Trøndelag in the period 2016–2019.
Diagnosis code (ICD-10) | Number (n) | |
---|---|---|
F20–29 | Schizophrenia, schizotypal and paranoid personality disorders | 6 |
F40–48 | Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform disorders | 15 |
F80–83 | Developmental disorders (of speech and language and general intellectual disabilities) | 19 |
F90 | Hyperkinetic disorders (ADHD) | 51 |
F91–94 | Behavioural and emotional disorders in childhood | 13 |
F95 | Tics | 7 |
A total of 27 children (22 %) received additional diagnoses, most commonly ADHD, at the same time as being diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder (n = 19, other data not shown). Four of 125 children were also diagnosed with an intellectual disability (with or without an accompanying neurological disorder, data not shown).
Discussion
This study appears to suggest that there is no excess prevalence of autism spectrum disorders in children of mothers with a different national background if they are diagnosed at the age of 10–16 years. This differs from the findings of our earlier study where we established significant excess prevalence of autism in preschool children of mothers with a different national background (13). Children who received an autism spectrum diagnosis while of school age were generally diagnosed with either Asperger syndrome or unspecified pervasive developmental disorder and their intellectual ability was, as expected, most often in the normal range.
These findings are in line with earlier studies that similarly did not establish a higher prevalence of autism spectrum disorders in children aged between 10 and 16 from an immigrant background and with normal cognitive abilities (8, 9). Magnusson et al.'s study indicated that autism with and without an accompanying intellectual disability may have different aetiologies and that these groups should therefore be studied separately (9). Because most autistic children with developmental comorbidity are diagnosed at the preschool stage, their aetiology may differ from that of children who receive an autism spectrum diagnosis at a later stage. Morinaga et al. discuss potential causes of an elevated risk of autism spectrum disorders in immigrant families (16). Some of these are linked directly to the mother's migration, which is why we have chosen to specify how many children were born in a country other than Norway.
Health-seeking behaviours
Studies have shown that young autistic children of immigrant parents have a heavier symptom load than those from a Norwegian background, which may affect the approach to seeking help from the health service (1, 17). However, we have little knowledge about the health-seeking behaviours of parents with a different national background and children with neurodevelopmental disorders. In 2020, a Swedish study examined parents from diverse cultural, ethnic and language backgrounds, and found that their backgrounds did not affect their behaviours when seeking help with autism symptoms in their own children (18).
The study of preschool children from Trøndelag also did not suggest this (13). Hansen et al. found that ADHD occurred less frequently among children of parents from an immigrant background and discussed the extent to which this might be due to the parents' health-seeking behaviours, understanding of the symptoms or other cultural issues (12). Can similar factors be significant in cases of autism spectrum disorders in children whose cognitive ability is in the normal range?
Comorbidity
In our cohort, 59 % of the children had received one or more neuropsychiatric or psychiatric diagnoses, most commonly ADHD, before they were diagnosed with an autism spectrum disorder. We know that children with autism are at considerable risk of neuropsychiatric comorbidity (19–21). Kiselev et al. described in a study from 2020 that 65 % of those with an autism diagnosis had one or more accompanying neuropsychiatric diagnoses (20). We know of several shared genetic vulnerability factors, as well as shared environmental factors, that may predispose to several neurodevelopmental disorders (22–24). Furthermore, apart from the fact that many with autism have accompanying neuropsychiatric disorders, we can observe similar symptoms – including when patients have no comorbid diagnosis. In a study of adults with ADHD, Hayashi et al. found that 23.3 % scored above the autism threshold value in the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (25).
The fact that many children receive other psychiatric diagnoses first, raises the question of whether this could have been avoided if they had received the autism diagnosis at an earlier stage and therefore would have received better adaptive support and more understanding. There are few studies that describe comorbidity in relation to age at the time of diagnosis. For a long time, the ICD-10 guidelines precluded the possibility of ADHD comorbidity. This may have led to under-reporting and can have influenced numbers in respect of the concurrent prevalence of these diagnoses. Rim et al. investigated this in a Korean register study and found increased prevalence of psychiatric comorbidity (except psychotic disorders) in people who received the autism diagnosis after the age of five (26).
The Autism Phenome Project followed up 75 children who were diagnosed with autism at the age of 2–3.5 years (27). This study found increasing severity of autism symptoms when the children developed comorbid psychiatric disorders. Of these children, 21 % met the criteria for an anxiety diagnosis at the age of 11, and a considerable proportion also experienced attention difficulties (28). Could it be that comorbid disorders amplify autism symptoms in children who at a younger age did not meet the diagnostic criteria? Or does this suggest that the aetiology of autism spectrum disorders has a different cognitive and emotional profile depending on age at the time of diagnosis (29)?
Strengths and weaknesses of the study
It is a strength of our study that we have a relatively complete cohort, in that 92 % of patients who met the criteria are included in the sample. This gives us a representative picture of school-age children in the relevant cohort. The size of the study is a weakness, as is the risk of false-negative findings (Type 2 errors). It is also possible that a larger geographical area and newer data would have increased the generalisability of the findings, and that a prospective study design could have provided more accurate data; we could for example have recorded maternal country of birth rather than national background. It is also a weakness that we did not include information about socio-economic status or genetic findings. This could have given us a more nuanced picture and will be important to include in future studies.
Conclusion
Based on the discrepancy between the findings of the two studies from Trøndelag, we believe it is important to specify age at the time of diagnosis in future autism studies. We also believe that there is reason to study aetiological factors and comorbidity separately based on age at the time of diagnosis.
The article has been peer reviewed.
- 1.
Zeidan J, Fombonne E, Scorah J et al. Global prevalence of autism: A systematic review update. Autism Res 2022; 15: 778–90. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 2.
Fombonne E. Epidemiological controversies in autism. Swiss Arch Neurol Psychiatr Psychother 2020 doi: 10.4414/sanp.2020.03084. [CrossRef]
- 3.
World Health Organization. International statistical classification of diseases and health related problems (The) ICD-10. Geneve: World Health Organization, 2004.
- 4.
Chiarotti F, Venerosi A. Epidemiology of autism spectrum disorders: a review of worldwide prevalence estimates since 2014. Brain Sci 2020; 10: 274. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 5.
Sacco R, Camilleri N, Eberhardt J et al. The prevalence of autism spectrum disorder in Europe. I: Carotenuto M, red. Autism Spectrum Disorders-Recent Advances and New Perspectives. London: IntechOpen, 2022.
- 6.
Sacco R, Camilleri N, Eberhardt J et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis on the prevalence of mental disorders among children and adolescents in Europe. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2024; 33: 2877–94. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 7.
Leader G, Hogan A, Chen JL et al. Age of autism spectrum disorder diagnosis and comorbidity in children and adolescents with autism spectrum disorder. Dev Neurorehabil 2022; 25: 29–37. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 8.
Haglund NG, Källén KB. Risk factors for autism and Asperger syndrome. Perinatal factors and migration. Autism 2011; 15: 163–83. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 9.
Magnusson C, Rai D, Goodman A et al. Migration and autism spectrum disorder: population-based study. Br J Psychiatry 2012; 201: 109–15. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 10.
Lehti V, Cheslack-Postava K, Gissler M et al. Parental migration and Asperger's syndrome. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2015; 24: 941–8. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 11.
Paulsrud K, Amiri Z, Drangsholt A et al. NOU 2020: 1. Tjenester til personer med autismespekterforstyrrelser og til personer med Tourettes syndrom. https://www.regjeringen.no/contentassets/747aa01b1b314d4780c1f49fd4c3ea95/nou-tjenester-til-personer-med-autismespekterforstyrrelser-og-til-personer-med-tourettes-syndrom.pdf Accessed 28.10.2024.
- 12.
Hansen T, Qureshi S, Gele A et al. Developmental disorders among Norwegian-born children with immigrant parents. Child Adolesc Psychiatry Ment Health 2023; 17: 3. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 13.
Eig KB, Brandkvist M, Lydersen S et al. Autismespekterforstyrrelser hos barn i førskolealder i Sør-Trøndelag 2016–19. Tidsskr Nor Legeforen 2022; 142. doi: 10.4045/tidsskr.21.0673. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 14.
Statistisk sentralbyrå. Innvandrere og norskfødte med innvandrerforeldre. https://www.ssb.no/befolkning/innvandrere/statistikk/innvandrere-og-norskfodte-med-innvandrerforeldre Accessed 18.10.2022.
- 15.
Statistisk sentralbyrå. Alders- og kjønnsfordeling i kommuner, fylker og hele landets befolkning. Tabell 07459. https://www.ssb.no/statbank/table/07459 Accessed 18.10.2022.
- 16.
Morinaga M, Rai D, Hollander AC et al. Migration or ethnic minority status and risk of autism spectrum disorders and intellectual disability: systematic review. Eur J Public Health 2021; 31: 304–12. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 17.
Bettencourt C, Garret-Gloanec N, Pellerin H et al. Migration is associated with baseline severity and progress over time in autism spectrum disorder: Evidence from a French prospective longitudinal study. PLoS One 2022; 17. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0272693. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 18.
Zakirova-Engstrand R, Hirvikoski T, Westling Allodi M et al. Culturally diverse families of young children with ASD in Sweden: Parental explanatory models. PLoS One 2020; 15. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0236329. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 19.
Hawks ZW, Constantino JN. Neuropsychiatric "comorbidity" as causal influence in autism. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2020; 59: 229–35. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 20.
Kiselev Y, Handal M, Hjellvik V et al. Nationwide study of neuropsychiatric comorbidity and medicines use in children with autism spectrum disorder in Norway. Front Psychiatry 2020; 11. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.596032. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 21.
Lai MC, Kassee C, Besney R et al. Prevalence of co-occurring mental health diagnoses in the autism population: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet Psychiatry 2019; 6: 819–29. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 22.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1101%2F224774 doi: 10.1101/224774. Grove J, Ripke S, Als TD et al. Common risk variants identified in autism spectrum disorder. BioRxiv. Preprint 27.11.2017. https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/224774v2 Accessed 28.10.2024 10.1101/224774.10.1101/224774[CrossRef]
- 23.
Rommelse NNJ, Franke B, Geurts HM et al. Shared heritability of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and autism spectrum disorder. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2010; 19: 281–95. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 24.
Xi T, Wu J. A review on the mechanism between different factors and the occurrence of autism and ADHD. Psychol Res Behav Manag 2021; 14: 393–403. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 25.
Hayashi W, Hanawa Y, Yuriko I et al. ASD symptoms in adults with ADHD: a preliminary study using the ADOS-2. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 2022; 272: 217–32. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 26.
Rim SJ, Kwak K, Park S. Risk of psychiatric comorbidity with autism spectrum disorder and its association with diagnosis timing using a nationally representative cohort. Res Autism Spectr Disord 2023; 104. doi: 10.1016/j.rasd.2023.102134. [CrossRef]
- 27.
Nordahl CW, Andrews DS, Dwyer P et al. The autism phenome project: toward identifying clinically meaningful subgroups of autism. Front Neurosci 2022; 15. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2021.786220. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 28.
Waizbard-Bartov E, Ferrer E, Heath B et al. Changes in the severity of autism symptom domains are related to mental health challenges during middle childhood. Autism 2024; 28: 1216–30. [PubMed][CrossRef]
- 29.
Casanova MF, Frye RE, Gillberg C et al. Editorial: Comorbidity and autism spectrum disorder. Front Psychiatry 2020; 11. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.617395. [PubMed][CrossRef]
Forfatterne av denne, og en tidligere artikkel i Tidsskriftet, presenterer data om insidensraten av autismespekterforstyrrelse hos barn med innvandrermødre i Sør-Trøndelag mellom 2016-2019 (1, 2). Forfatterne presenterer «innvandrerbakgrunn» som en risikofaktor eller årsak til autismespekterforstyrrelser, med det jeg mener er mangelfull empirisk dekning. Jeg har selv forsket på autismespekterdiagnoser hos barn, og mener artikkelforfatterne bruker upresise kategorier og trekker forhastede konklusjoner (3, 5).
Dersom innvandrerbakgrunn var en betydelig risikofaktor for autsimespekterforstyrrelser, burde det vise seg når man studerer forskjeller mellom geografiske områder. Det er vist at noen fylker i Norge har lavere forekomst av autismespekterforstyrrelser uten at innvandrerandelen er lavere i disse fylkene (3, 4).
I de to nevnte studiene tar forfatterne heller ikke hensyn til fedrenes landbakgrunn – kun mødrenes. De justerer heller ikke for foreldrenes alder, eller andre kjente risikofaktorer.
I artikkelen fra 2024 finner forfatterne at mors landbakgrunn synes å ha mindre betydning hos skolebarn enn hos førskolebarn som får diagnosen. Utvalget dekker imidlertid kun aldersgruppen skolebarn, 10-16 år (1). Hvorfor er 7-9-åringene ekskludert?. Samtidig mener jeg at det er en betydningsfull forskjell som de fant mellom aldersgruppene, der hyppigheten var 1 av 555 hos førskolebarn og 1 av 833 av skolebarn, selv om forskerne sier at det ikke er betydningsfull (1).
Litteratur:
1) Røe AB, Jullumstrø S, Eig KB et al. Autismediagnose hos skolebarn i Trøndelag Sør 2016–19. Tidsskr Nor Legeforen 2024; 144. doi 10.4045/tidsskr.24.0259.
2) Eig KB, Brandkvist MC, Lydersen S et al. Autismespekterforstyrrelser hos barn i førskolealder i Sør-Trøndelag 2016–19. Tidsskr Nor Legeforen 2022;142. doi: 10.4045/tidsskr.21.0673.
3) Øzerk M, Øzerk K. Autisme og pedagogikk. Oslo: Cappelen Damm Akademisk, 2020.
4) Surėn P, Bakken IJ, Lie KK et al. Fylkesvise forskjeller i registrert forekomst av autisme, AD/HD, epilepsi og cerebral parese i Norge. Tidsskr Nor Legefor 2013: 133(18):1929-34. doi: 10.4045/tidsskr.13.0050.
5) Özerk K. The issue of prevalence of autism/ASD. International Electronic Journal of Elementary Education, 2016; 9(2), 263–306.